After I post this today, I’m heading to the airport to pick up my critique partner, Linda Castillo. She lives in Amarillo and is flying in for a day just for a “sisterhood fix”. We’ll be joining with another critique partner, Jenna Mills, and doing our traditional dinner at Olive Garden (soup, salad, breadsticks—always!), perhaps with a glass of wine. We’re also going to drink some champagne from the infamous plastic cowboy boot mugs, to celebrate some very big deals which are working for Linda, and just being together. The champagne in the cowboy boots is another tradition, started with the first book sale in our then-all-unpublished critique group. The sale was mine, and the year was 1998. When my CPs looked for plastic champagne glasses to go with the bubbly they’d purchased, all they could find were the boots. Now, however, we wouldn’t dream of celebrating without those silly boot mugs.
But more importantly, we wouldn’t dream of missing the “Great Sisterhood rituals”, ones I believe all women perform with other women, across the world, and—who knows?—perhaps across the universe. There’s just something in our makeup that leads us to create bonds with other women. Perhaps it’s our intuitive or nurturing tendencies, or maybe our openness to our feelings, but we women innately reach out to one another, especially in times of great emotions, be they joy or sadness.
I grew up with two brothers, so I never had the experience of a biological sister, or the quibbling and the love-hate relationship sisters seem to share. But I had three best friends, and we were inseparable through the school years. One of those, Beth, has reconnected with me, and we still correspond. I added another friend in the sixth grade, Janet, who became my closest friend, and still is, after forty plus years and with many miles between us. She and I are so in sync that when we see each other, even after months apart, it’s like we were never separated. When we get together, it’s sixth grade again (telling dirty jokes and laughing uproariously), or our first crushes on guys, our first kisses, our marriages (we were maid of honor and matron of honor for each other), the birth of our children—and the death of our mothers. Two other friends from high school and early adulthood—Debbie and Jennifer—have also remained very close despite both of them living across the country (and in other countries). These lifelong friends and I walk this Earth in total kinship and understanding.
It’s the same with my critique partners. We might go weeks or months without actually seeing each other, but that bond never wavers. If one of us hurts or is troubled, the others send support and encouragement and love. It is that same basic message of empowering love that fuels the romances we write and read. It’s just there, flowing out of us as naturally as a spring flows from the ground.
Some guys have bonding experiences with other guys, but it’s not the same. Because no matter how sensitive, aware, or self-actualized guys become, they’re just not tapped into that mystical goddess energy that connects women the world over. It’s innate within us, and it gives us a sense of oneness with other women that is superseded only by our bonds with our children. I’m not convinced even husbands can compete with this oneness, although they might come close.
We women are born into this Great Sisterhood—no initiation or secret handshake necessary. How wonderful, how glorious, how female!
Today I’ll drink champagne from a scratched plastic cowboy boot mug. And not only will I toast my critique partners’ amazing successes, I will also celebrate being a woman.
How many of you have special friendships that have endured time and distance? Here’s to those friendships, and to all of you, members of the Great Sisterhood.
~ Catherine





















I totally agree with you Catherine. I know alot of writers who poo poo the idea of critique groups, but when you find one that works, I think they’re priceless. My critique group, The Plot Queens (www.plotqueens.com) have become an extended family. My best friends in the world. In 2005, I really wanted to attend my first RWA conference and just couldn’t come up with the money. This was before I sold to Berkley, and so I just couldn’t justify spending that kind of money when I didn’t have any major reason for going except that I “just wanted to.” That year for Christmas at our Plot Queen party, I was given a little travel jar. I opened it, found the conference registration, plane ticket, and hotel room rect’s inside. All found or donated to me by my writer/ industry friends who wanted me to have that experience even more than I do. I don’t cry. I’m even a little emotionally uptight. But I bawled like a baby. I’ve never in my life had friends that would do something like that for me.
Comment by Heather — October 30, 2006 @ 11:59 am
My CP lives across the country…we’ve never met, but I consider her the best friend I’ve ever had. We talk every day and the distance doesn’t matter. We’ve had a strong connection from day one (not to mention I dont know what I’d do without her…so I’m damn well not letting hre slip away!)
Comment by Alyssa Brooks — October 30, 2006 @ 12:14 pm
What a wonderful post, Catherine! It’s funny, I’m just about to do a girl-bonding afternoon tomorrow with a girlfriend I haven’t seen in almost a year. We’re so excited, going to the Brooklyn Botanic Gardens. I am stressed and behind in my deadlines but I have to research the setting for my next coffeehouse mystery and she lives close by, so I asked her if she can spare any time to have lunch at the garden restaurant, then we can bundle up and take a look at the fall gardens. I was so happy when she said yes (she’s under some crazy deadlines too). But I guess we both know sometimes you need to take time out and reconnect because life just never slows down enough…We’ve been through a lot together, and really, that’s what makes sisters, biological or not!
Luv,
Cleo Coyle
Latest release…Coffeehouse Mystery #4: Murder Most Froth
An IMBA bestseller!
Comment by Cleo — October 30, 2006 @ 3:13 pm
I just had lunch with my best friend of 25+ years. This isn’t a frequent happening as I am retired and she still works and we live about 100 miles apart.
Comment by Estella — October 30, 2006 @ 5:43 pm
I am lucky enough to have my very own sisters as my best friends. Its a wonderful connection that the menfolk in my family (no daughters for me) just don’t get.
Comment by cathy — October 30, 2006 @ 7:50 pm